# Your Re-Ballot Starts On Day One: Gathering BID Re-Ballot Evidence Year By Year

URL: https://www.starien.com/blog/bid-re-ballot-evidence-starts-on-day-one
Published: 2026-09-26
Author: Geoffrey Moffett
Topics: business improvement districts, levy payers, ballot, renewal, evidence

> Strong BID re-ballot evidence is built over five years, not five months. A year-by-year plan for gathering proof, stories and data so your renewal case writes itself.

## Quick answer

BID re-ballot evidence should be gathered throughout the term, not in the final months. Set measures linked to your business plan promises, keep a simple evidence log, collect levy payer stories and feedback every year, and review progress annually, so the renewal case is built from five years of proof.

## Key takeaways

- Link every measure to a promise in your business plan.
- A simple monthly evidence log beats a frantic search in year five.
- Stories and testimonials need collecting while the moment is fresh.
- Annual reviews let you fix weak areas long before the ballot.

Many BIDs treat renewal as a final-year sprint. A consultant arrives, surveys go out, someone tries to remember what happened in year two. The result is often a rushed case with thin proof. The BIDs that renew confidently tend to do something simpler: they gather BID re-ballot evidence quietly, steadily, from the very first day of the term.

## Why Last-Minute Evidence Is Weak Evidence

When you collect evidence in a hurry:

- photos and figures from early years are lost or incomplete;
- testimonials are vague, because the moment has passed;
- data gaps can't be filled retrospectively;
- the story feels assembled, not lived.

Levy payers notice. A renewal case built from five years of consistent evidence feels trustworthy, because it is.

## Building Your BID Re-Ballot Evidence Framework

### Start With Your Promises

Take your business plan and list every promise. For each, write down:

- what success looks like;
- how you'll measure it;
- where the evidence will come from;
- who's responsible for collecting it.

Keep measures realistic. If you can't measure something properly, find a sensible proxy or describe it honestly.

### Set Up An Evidence Log

A shared spreadsheet or folder, organised by business plan theme. Every month, someone adds:

- what was delivered;
- any numbers, with sources;
- photos and press coverage;
- feedback and quotes.

Ten minutes a month. That's all it takes to avoid a year-five panic. It also feeds your [annual report](/blog/writing-your-bid-annual-report-with-ai/) and funding bids.

## A Year-By-Year Plan

### Year One: Set Baselines

- Record the starting point for each measure: footfall, member digital presence, vacancies, perceptions, whatever matters to your plan.
- Run a baseline levy payer survey.
- Start the evidence log.
- Photograph the town as it is.

### Year Two: Build The Habit

- Keep the log going monthly.
- Collect the first testimonials after successful projects.
- Share progress with levy payers in plain language.
- Fix any measures that are proving impossible to collect.

### Year Three: Mid-Term Check

- Run a mid-term levy payer survey, repeating key baseline questions.
- Review every promise: on track, behind or changed?
- Be honest with the board about weak areas, and adjust delivery.
- Start noting the themes levy payers want for a next term.

### Year Four: Fill The Gaps

- Focus delivery on any promises at risk.
- Gather deeper case studies, including short videos, from a range of business types.
- Identify likely supporters and sceptics, and listen to both.
- Start drafting the renewal story.

### Year Five: Campaign

- Pull five years of evidence into a clear, honest renewal case.
- Consult on the new business plan.
- Share stories through every channel.
- Run the formal ballot campaign.

## Collecting Stories While They're Fresh

Numbers persuade boards. Stories persuade levy payers. Build story collection into everyday work:

- after every event, ask two or three businesses how it went for them;
- after support sessions, ask attendees what changed;
- note short quotes on walkabouts, and follow up for permission;
- film quick clips at events, with consent.

Store them in the evidence log, tagged by theme and sector.

## Using AI To Make Sense Of It

By year five you may have hundreds of entries. An AI writing assistant can help you:

- summarise each theme's evidence into a short narrative;
- spot gaps where proof is thin;
- group feedback into themes, as in our guide to analysing [consultation responses](/blog/making-sense-of-bid-consultation-responses-with-ai/);
- draft different versions of the case for different audiences.

Every fact must still be checked against the log. AI organises; it doesn't invent.

## What A Good Evidence Log Entry Looks Like

Consistency matters more than detail. A simple format for every entry:

| Field | Example |
|---|---|
| Date | Month and year |
| Theme | Marketing and events |
| What happened | Summer family trail across the town centre |
| Measure | Trail cards handed out and returned, from our own count |
| Feedback | Two quotes from participating shops, permission recorded |
| Evidence | Photos folder link, social post link, press cutting |
| Lessons | Start promotion earlier; some shops ran out of cards |

Anyone on the team should be able to add an entry in a few minutes, and anyone reading it in four years' time should understand what happened.

### Include The Quiet Work

Advocacy, problem-solving and behind-the-scenes support are easy to forget because they don't produce photos. Log them too: a parking issue raised with the council, a member helped through a difficult planning question. At renewal, this quiet work often surprises levy payers who didn't know it happened.

## Be Honest About What Didn't Work

Levy payers are business people. They know not everything succeeds. A renewal case that admits "this project didn't deliver what we hoped, so we changed approach" is far more credible than one that claims every promise was met in full.

## Pitfalls To Avoid

- **Measuring too much.** Pick a handful of meaningful measures per theme.
- **Only collecting positive feedback.** Criticism helps you improve, and acknowledging it builds trust.
- **Relying on one person.** If the manager leaves, the evidence shouldn't leave with them.
- **Forgetting permissions.** Record consent for every quote, photo and video.
- **Hiding evidence until year five.** Share progress every year. Levy payers shouldn't be surprised at renewal.

## Evidence Log Checklist

- Every business plan promise has a measure and an owner.
- Baselines recorded in year one.
- Monthly log entries.
- Stories collected after key moments.
- Permissions recorded.
- Annual review with the board.

## How Starien Can Help

We supported Coleraine BID for six years, including the digital side of its successful re-ballot, so we know what a renewal case needs. Read more about our [work with Coleraine BID](/coleraine-business-improvement-district/) or [talk to us](/contact/) about building your evidence framework through Digital For BIDs.

## Frequently asked questions

### When should a BID start preparing for its re-ballot?

From the first day of the term. The strongest renewal cases are built on evidence gathered steadily over five years, with the formal campaign starting in the final year or so.

### What evidence do levy payers want to see?

Clear proof that the BID delivered what it promised, examples of how businesses like theirs benefited, honest reporting on what didn't work, and a credible plan for the next term.

### How do we collect testimonials from levy payers?

Ask soon after a positive moment, like a successful event or helpful support session. Keep it short, record their words accurately, and get written permission to use their name and business.
