MarketingBusiness

Fad Or Future: How To Judge Which Marketing Trends Are Worth Following

A simple way for small business owners to judge which marketing trends are worth following, and which to politely ignore, without missing the shifts that matter.

Geoffrey Moffett 4 Min Read

Quick Answer

To judge which marketing trends are worth following, ask whether the trend changes how your customers find, choose or return to you, whether you can sustain it with the time you have, whether it builds something lasting and whether a small, cheap test is possible. Trends that score well on those questions deserve a trial; the rest can wait.

Key Takeaways

  • Judge trends by your customers' behaviour, not by headlines.
  • Prefer trends that build lasting assets, like an email list or reputation.
  • Test small and cheap before committing time or money.
  • Review trends twice a year rather than reacting to every one.
In This Article

Knowing which marketing trends are worth following is a skill most small business owners never get taught. Every week there's a new platform, feature, format or "must-do" strategy. Follow them all and you'll burn out. Ignore them all and you might miss something that genuinely changes how customers find you.

Here's a simple way to tell the difference, so you can make calm, confident decisions.

Marketing news is noisy. Platforms promote new features. Agencies and software companies have products to sell. Social media rewards hot takes. And because many trends start with big brands, it's hard to see whether they'll matter for a café in Carrickfergus or an accountant in Armagh.

The trick is to stop asking "Is this trending?" and start asking "Does this matter to my customers?"

Score each trend from 0 to 2 on these questions.

1. Does It Change How My Customers Behave

Is there real evidence your customers are finding, choosing or buying differently because of it? Ask a few customers. Watch your own enquiries. If your customers aren't doing it, it can wait.

2. Can I Sustain It

Could you keep it going for six months with the time and skills you actually have? A trend that needs daily effort you can't give will fizzle out.

3. Does It Build Something Lasting

Does it build an asset, like an email list, reputation, reviews, useful content or community, or does the value disappear the moment you stop? Lasting assets are usually worth more.

4. Does It Fit My Brand

Would it feel natural for your business, or would it look like you're trying too hard? Customers notice when a business jumps on something that doesn't suit it.

5. Can I Test It Small

Is there a cheap, quick way to try it, like four weeks, one campaign or one post a week? If the only option is a big commitment, be more cautious.

Scoring: 8–10, worth a proper trial. 5–7, worth a small test or keeping an eye on. 0–4, politely ignore for now.

Based on that test, some of the current shifts tend to score well for many small businesses:

  • AI search and answer engines, because they affect how customers find businesses and reward clear information you need anyway. Our guide to answer engines explains why.
  • Owning your audience through email, because it builds a lasting asset.
  • Short-form video for visual businesses, because it's cheap to test and widely used for discovery.
  • Community-led marketing, because it builds loyalty and suits close-knit local markets.
  • Brand-new platforms your customers haven't joined.
  • Expensive tech that needs large audiences to pay off.
  • Fully automated content that sounds generic.
  • Viral challenges that don't fit your business.

That doesn't mean they're bad, just that they're rarely the best use of a small team's time.

How To Run A Small Test

  1. Define success before you start, like "ten new email sign-ups" or "three enquiries mentioning the video".
  2. Set a time limit, usually four to eight weeks.
  3. Do it properly for that period, not half-heartedly.
  4. Review honestly at the end: keep, adjust or drop.

Write down what you learned either way. A failed test that cost little is still useful.

A Made-Up Example

A made-up yoga studio in Holywood hears it should launch a podcast. It scores the idea: customers aren't asking for it (0), time is tight (0), it would build content (1), it fits the brand (2), but there's no cheap way to test (0). Total: 3. Parked. It then scores short weekly videos of stretches: customers already watch them (2), easy to sustain (2), builds a library (2), fits the brand (2), cheap to test (2). Total: 10. It runs a six-week trial and gets new class bookings mentioning the videos.

Where To Get Trustworthy Signals

Some sources are more useful than others when judging a trend:

  • Your own customers. Ask how they found you and what they use. Nothing beats this.
  • Your own data. Search Console, Google Business Profile and email reports show real behaviour.
  • Businesses like yours. Peers in your sector or town, through a BID, chamber or online community, often know what's working before the headlines do.
  • Official platform announcements, for facts about features, rather than opinions about them.

Be more sceptical of sources selling something connected to the trend, and of anything that promises guaranteed results.

Sometimes a fad sits on top of a real trend. A particular app might fade, while the underlying habit, such as people searching through video, sticks around. When a fad passes, ask what behaviour was underneath it. That's often the bit worth paying attention to.

Make Trend Reviews A Habit

Twice a year, set aside an hour:

  • List the trends you've heard about.
  • Score each one.
  • Pick at most one or two to test.
  • Check how previous tests went.

Between reviews, jot ideas in a note rather than reacting immediately. Most trends will still be there in three months, and some will have quietly disappeared.

Don't Forget The Basics

The most reliable marketing is often the least trendy: a clear website, an accurate Google listing, steady reviews, a regular email and great customer service. If those aren't in place, they'll almost always score higher than anything new.

Want A Sounding Board

Sometimes it helps to talk ideas through with someone who knows the landscape. Our 1-1 Coaching sessions are a friendly place to weigh up new trends and decide what's worth your time.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if a marketing trend is a fad?

Fads tend to be driven by hype, suit only a few types of business and fade quickly. Lasting trends usually reflect a real change in how people behave, like how they search, shop or communicate.

Should small businesses be early adopters?

Only when the trend clearly fits your customers and the test is cheap. Most small businesses do well by being early followers, adopting once a trend has proved useful.

How often should I review marketing trends?

Twice a year is plenty for most small businesses, ideally when planning for the year and again at the halfway point.

What if my competitors jump on a trend?

Watch what happens, ask whether it's bringing them customers and decide calmly. Copying competitors without a reason often wastes time.

Written By

Geoffrey Moffett

More Articles
More In Marketing

Back To Top