Business Improvement DistrictsAI

Making Sense Of BID Consultation Responses With AI

Got hundreds of survey comments and consultation responses? How BIDs can use AI to sort, summarise and report on them quickly, fairly and without losing the voice of levy payers.

Geoffrey Moffett 4 Min Read

Quick Answer

AI can speed up the analysis of BID consultation responses by grouping open-text responses into themes, counting how often each comes up and pulling out representative quotes. Remove personal details first, check the themes against the original comments, and report back to levy payers on what you heard and what you'll do.

Key Takeaways

  • Strip names and contact details before putting responses into any AI tool.
  • Ask AI to suggest themes, then check a sample of responses against them yourself.
  • Keep minority views visible, because a summary can quietly erase them.
  • Close the loop by telling levy payers what you heard and what changes.
In This Article

Consultations generate a lot of words. Business plan surveys, perception studies, post-event feedback, pre-ballot conversations. The multiple-choice questions are easy to chart. The open comments, often the most valuable part, end up in a spreadsheet nobody has time to read properly. AI can change that, and making sense of BID consultation responses is one of the most useful, least flashy things it does.

Why BID Consultation Responses Get Ignored

A busy BID team gets several hundred comments back. Reading them all, sorting them and writing a fair summary can take days. So it gets skimmed, and the summary ends up reflecting whatever the reader remembered, or agreed with.

That's a problem, because levy payers who took the time to write something notice when nothing changes. And at renewal time, being able to say "you told us this, so we did that" is powerful.

Step 1: Prepare The Data Properly

Remove Personal Details

Before anything goes near an AI tool, strip out names, email addresses, phone numbers and anything else that identifies an individual. Business names can identify people too, especially sole traders, so consider replacing them with a sector label like "café" or "salon".

Keep Useful Context

Do keep non-identifying context that helps analysis, such as sector, street or zone, or size band, if you collected it. It lets you see whether retailers and hospitality businesses feel differently.

Use Approved Tools

Follow your organisation's AI policy. If you don't have one yet, our one-page AI policy for small BID teams is a good place to start.

Step 2: Let AI Suggest Themes

Paste the anonymised comments into an AI assistant like ChatGPT or Claude, in batches if there are many, and ask:

These are anonymised comments from a survey of businesses in a town centre business improvement district. Group them into themes. For each theme, give a short description, roughly how many comments fit it, and two or three representative quotes copied exactly. List any comments that don't fit a theme. Don't invent quotes.

You'll get a first pass in minutes.

Step 3: Check The Themes Yourself

This step is not optional.

Spot Check

Take a random sample of twenty or thirty comments and sort them into the AI's themes yourself. If many don't fit, or the counts look off, refine the themes and run it again.

Read For What AI Misses

AI can miss sarcasm, local references, nicknames for places and comments that are short but important. "Parking. Again." means something specific in most towns.

Protect Minority Views

Summaries naturally favour common opinions. Ask the AI specifically: "What views appear in only a few comments but could be important?" Then read those yourself. Sometimes the one comment about accessibility or safety matters more than fifty about Christmas lights.

Step 4: Turn Themes Into Findings

Now build a simple findings table:

ThemeRoughly how many raised itTypical quoteWhat we'll do
Parking and accessMany"..."Raise with council, share parking guide
Want more digital helpSome"..."Pilot drop-in clinics

AI can help draft the "what we'll do" column as options, but the decisions are the board's and the team's.

Step 5: Report Back

Closing the loop is where trust is built.

For Levy Payers

A short "you said, we did" email or one-page summary. Main themes, a couple of quotes, the actions, and a thank you.

For The Board

The full findings table, method notes (including how you used AI and checked it), and recommendations.

For The Public

Where relevant, a brief summary for local media or your town website. It shows the BID listens.

Designing Your Next Consultation With Analysis In Mind

Analysis is much easier if the consultation is designed for it. A few small choices help:

Ask Fewer, Sharper Open Questions

"Any other comments?" produces a bit of everything. "What one thing would make the biggest difference to your business in the town centre next year?" produces answers you can group and act on.

Collect Simple Context

A tick box for sector and one for location within the district costs respondents seconds and makes your analysis far richer.

Say How You'll Use It

Tell people their comments will be anonymised and summarised. It builds trust, and you'll often get more candid answers.

Using AI For Other Feedback

The same approach works for:

  • post-event feedback forms;
  • comments from drop-in sessions;
  • notes from walkabout conversations with levy payers;
  • social media comments on a campaign.

Over a year, this builds a rich picture of what your levy payers think, which is exactly the evidence you'll want for your renewal ballot campaign.

Pitfalls To Avoid

  • Trusting the counts blindly. AI estimates. Check against a sample.
  • Leaving personal data in. Anonymise first, every time.
  • Cherry-picking quotes. Include critical voices in your report. Levy payers respect honesty.
  • Analysing and not acting. If nothing changes, the next consultation gets fewer responses.

A Quick Checklist

  • Data anonymised and stored securely.
  • Themes suggested by AI, checked by a person.
  • Minority views reviewed.
  • Findings table agreed by the team.
  • "You said, we did" sent to levy payers.

How Starien Can Help

We help BIDs gather and use member feedback through surveys, portals and AI workflows as part of Digital For BIDs. If you're sitting on a pile of comments and don't know where to start, or want a better way to run your next consultation, get in touch.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can AI analyse survey comments for a BID?

Yes. AI is good at grouping open-text comments into themes, summarising them and finding typical quotes. It should be checked by a person, because it can miss sarcasm, local references or less common but important views.

How do we keep consultation data private when using AI?

Remove names, emails, business names where they identify someone, and any other personal details before analysis, and only use tools your organisation has approved. Keep the original data stored securely.

How should a BID report consultation results?

Share the main themes, how many people raised each, a few representative quotes, notable minority views, and clear actions. A short 'you said, we did' summary works well for levy payers.

Written By

Geoffrey Moffett

More Articles

Back To Top