AINorthern Ireland

Measuring AI Impact In Belfast Council Communications Without Vanity Metrics

How a large council like Belfast could measure whether AI is genuinely helping its communications in 2027, using meaningful measures of time, quality, reach and trust.

Geoffrey Moffett 4 Min Read

Quick Answer

Measuring AI impact in Belfast council communications means looking at time saved on specific tasks, accuracy and errors caught, accessibility, resident outcomes such as fewer repeat enquiries, and trust, rather than counting posts or likes. A simple baseline before AI is introduced makes comparison possible.

Key Takeaways

  • More content isn't the goal; better outcomes for residents are.
  • Record a baseline for each task before introducing AI.
  • Errors caught during checking are a sign the safeguards work, so track them.
  • Combine numbers with staff and resident feedback, and review quarterly as tools change.
In This Article

It's tempting to judge AI by output: more posts, more press releases, more web pages, faster. In a big city council, that can look impressive on a slide. But more content isn't the point. Measuring AI impact in Belfast council communications should answer a simpler question: are residents, visitors and businesses better served, and are staff spending their time on the right things?

Here's a practical approach a council like Belfast's could use from spring 2027. AI tools and how people use them are changing quickly, so review your measures every quarter.

Why Vanity Metrics Mislead

Counting outputs can actually reward the wrong behaviour. If AI doubles the number of social posts, but residents scroll past them, nothing has improved. Worse, more content means more to check and more chance of errors.

Common vanity metrics to treat with caution:

  • number of posts or releases published;
  • raw follower counts;
  • impressions without context;
  • "number of staff using AI".

They're not useless, but they're not impact.

Measuring AI Impact In Belfast Council Communications: Five Areas

1. Time Saved On Specific Tasks

Pick five or six repeated tasks, such as coverage summaries, social versions of releases, plain-English summaries of reports, FAQ drafts and enquiry replies. Before introducing AI, record how long each takes. Then record the time with AI, including checking. Compare over several weeks.

Be honest: some tasks won't get faster, and that's useful to know.

2. Quality And Accuracy

Track:

  • errors caught at the checking stage, by type (facts, tone, names, dates);
  • errors that reached the public, and how they were corrected;
  • feedback from editors and approvers.

A falling error rate over time shows prompts and training are improving. Errors caught show safeguards are working.

3. Accessibility

AI can make accessibility work easier. Measure:

  • share of images with good alt text;
  • share of videos with accurate captions;
  • number of plain-English or easy-read versions produced;
  • readability scores on key pages.

4. Resident Outcomes

The most meaningful measures sit closest to residents:

  • fewer repeat enquiries on topics where content was improved;
  • more people reaching the right service page from social posts;
  • faster response times on comments that need replies;
  • better answers from AI assistants to common resident questions, tested monthly.

5. Trust And Confidence

Harder to measure, but important:

  • resident feedback on clarity and helpfulness;
  • complaints related to AI use;
  • staff confidence, surveyed before and after training;
  • members' and partners' feedback.

Who Should Own The Measures

In a large organisation, measurement often falls between teams. A practical split could be:

  • communications owns content quality, accessibility and channel measures;
  • customer services shares enquiry data and themes;
  • digital or web teams own page performance and AI search testing;
  • information governance reviews incidents and data protection issues.

One person pulls it together each quarter. Without a named owner, dashboards quietly stop being updated.

Qualitative Evidence Counts

Some of the most persuasive evidence won't be a number. A press officer saying "I finally had time to visit three community groups this month" or a resident commenting that a notice was "the first one I've understood" tells you something important. Collect short quotes from staff and residents, with permission, alongside the figures.

Setting Up A Simple Dashboard

Keep it to one page. For each measure: the baseline, the current figure, the direction of travel and a short comment. AI can help draft the commentary from the numbers, but a person checks it says what the data actually shows.

Reporting Honestly

When reporting to senior managers or members:

  • include what hasn't worked as well as what has;
  • separate time saved from time reinvested (for example, into more neighbourhood stories);
  • avoid claiming savings that haven't been measured;
  • explain safeguards and any incidents.

Honest reporting builds trust in the whole programme.

A Made-Up Example

Imagine a team piloting AI for turning committee reports into plain-English web summaries. Baseline: two hours each. With AI and checking: around forty-five minutes. Errors caught at checking: a handful in the first month, fewer by the third. Resident outcome: the summary pages get more visits than the full reports, and fewer people phone with basic questions. That's a story worth telling. A dashboard that only said "40 summaries published" would have missed the point.

Timing Around 2027

A baseline captured in early 2027 lets you see results by summer, when events and visitor season put the system under pressure. Review again in autumn and adjust before the busy winter period.

Keeping Data Use Proportionate

Measurement shouldn't create new privacy risks. Use anonymised or aggregated data where possible, follow UK GDPR and the council's data protection policies, and refer to the ICO's guidance on AI and the UK Government's AI playbook for the public sector.

Pitfalls To Avoid

  • No baseline. Without one, you can't show change.
  • Measuring everything. Pick a few meaningful measures.
  • Ignoring checking time. AI time savings should include review time.
  • Treating numbers as the whole story. Combine them with feedback.

How Starien Can Help

Starien is a small digital marketing team based in Coleraine, working since 2015 with public sector teams, charities and businesses. Over six years leading Coleraine BID's digital delivery, we learned to report results that boards cared about, from 10,700+ Facebook followers to a 40%+ engagement increase, and what sat behind them. Our AI Coaching helps teams set up practical measures alongside their AI workflows, and our Public Relations support can help tell the story well.

We help Belfast businesses measure what matters in their marketing too, with websites, social media and AEO, and owners can learn the basics in Launchpad. Get in touch for a chat.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are vanity metrics in council communications?

Measures that look impressive but don't show real impact, such as total posts published, raw follower counts or impressions, without any link to residents getting what they need.

How can a council measure time saved by AI?

Choose specific tasks, record how long they take before AI is introduced, then record how long they take with AI including checking time. Compare over several weeks.

Should a council measure AI errors?

Yes. Logging errors caught at the checking stage shows where AI is weak, helps improve prompts and training, and demonstrates that human oversight is working.

Written By

Geoffrey Moffett

More Articles
More In AI

Back To Top