KajabiEmail Marketing

How To Move Your Email List To Kajabi Without Losing Deliverability

Your email list is one of your most valuable assets. How to move your email list to Kajabi carefully: export, consent, tags, authentication and a gentle warm-up.

Geoffrey Moffett 4 Min Read

Quick Answer

To move your email list to Kajabi safely, clean the list before exporting, keep records of consent, map your old tags to a simple new structure, authenticate your sending domain in Kajabi and warm up gradually by emailing your most engaged subscribers first. Never import people who didn't opt in to hear from you.

Key Takeaways

  • Clean before you move. Don't carry dead weight to a new platform.
  • Only import people who genuinely opted in, and keep consent records.
  • Authenticate your domain before your first send from Kajabi.
  • Warm up by emailing engaged subscribers first, then widen gradually.
In This Article

Your email list may be the most valuable thing in your business. It's an audience you own, built over years. When you move platforms, it deserves careful handling. Here's how to move your email list to Kajabi without losing subscribers, consent records or the inbox placement you've worked hard for.

Why Care Matters

Email providers judge senders partly on history. When you start sending from a new platform, some of that history resets. A careless move, such as importing everyone and blasting a big email on day one, can send your messages to spam. A careful move protects your reputation.

Step 1: Clean Before You Export

Don't carry dead weight to your new home. Before exporting:

  • remove bounced and invalid addresses;
  • remove obvious fake or junk sign-ups;
  • consider a short re-engagement email campaign on your old platform, then remove non-responders;
  • note any unsubscribed contacts, so they aren't accidentally re-added.

A smaller, cleaner list will perform better in Kajabi from the start.

Step 2: Export Carefully

From your old platform, export:

  • email addresses and names;
  • tags, groups or segments;
  • sign-up dates and sources, if available;
  • consent information, if your old platform stores it.

Keep a safe copy of the original export, untouched, in case you need to check something later.

Only import people who genuinely opted in to hear from you. That means:

  • no bought or borrowed lists;
  • no business cards or event lists added without permission;
  • no customers of someone else's business.

In the UK and Ireland, data protection and electronic marketing rules expect you to have a lawful basis to email people. Keep records of how and when each subscriber joined. If you're unsure about a group of contacts, leave them out or take advice.

Step 4: Map Your Tags

Old platforms often have years of accumulated tags and groups. Moving is the perfect time to simplify.

  • List your old tags.
  • Decide which matter: source, interest, customer status.
  • Map old tags to a new, consistent naming pattern.
  • Leave behind tags nobody uses.

Our simple Kajabi tagging strategy gives a structure you can map to.

Step 5: Authenticate Your Domain In Kajabi

Before sending a single email, set up your sending domain in Kajabi and add the authentication records it asks for to your DNS settings. This helps email providers trust that your emails really come from you. Follow Kajabi's current help guidance, or ask someone experienced if DNS isn't your thing.

See email deliverability basics for Kajabi creators for why this matters so much.

Step 6: Import In Sensible Batches

When importing:

  • import from a tidy file with clear columns;
  • apply the right tags during import, where possible;
  • consider importing customers, engaged subscribers and less-engaged subscribers as separate groups with separate tags, so you can warm up gradually;
  • check a handful of imported contacts to make sure names and tags look right.

How To Move Your Email List To Kajabi And Warm Up

Don't email everyone on day one. Instead:

  1. Week 1: email your most engaged subscribers, such as recent clickers and customers.
  2. Week 2: add the next most engaged group.
  3. Week 3 onwards: include the rest of your active list.

Send genuinely useful, engaging emails during this period, not a big sales push. Positive engagement builds your reputation on the new setup.

Rebuild Key Sequences

Your welcome, onboarding and nurture sequences need to be recreated in Kajabi. Take the chance to improve them:

  • update dates, links and offers;
  • shorten anything that's grown too long;
  • check every link points to your new Kajabi pages.

Make sure new subscribers from Kajabi forms are added to the right sequence before you switch your opt-in forms over.

Switch Your Forms

Only once Kajabi is ready:

  • replace sign-up forms on your website, landing pages and lead magnets;
  • update links in social bios and podcast notes;
  • test each form to make sure tags and sequences apply.

Keep your old platform active for a short overlap, in case a forgotten form is still collecting sign-ups.

Keep Your Emails Recognisable

Subscribers decide in a split second whether to open an email, mostly based on the sender name and subject line. After a move, keep both familiar:

  • use the same sender name you used before;
  • keep a similar subject style for your newsletter;
  • keep the same tone and sign-off.

If your emails will look noticeably different, add a friendly line: "You might notice my emails look a little different. Same me, new home." It reassures people and reduces the chance of someone marking you as spam because they didn't recognise you.

Pitfalls To Avoid

  • Importing everyone, unchecked. Clean and check consent first.
  • Skipping authentication. It's essential.
  • A day-one blast. Warm up gradually.
  • Re-adding unsubscribed contacts. Keep that list separate and respected.
  • Forgetting old forms. Hunt them all down.

A Made-Up Example

Imagine a yoga teacher moving several thousand subscribers to Kajabi. She cleans out bounces and runs a re-engagement campaign first, removing a large inactive group. She imports customers, engaged readers and others with separate tags, authenticates her domain and sends her first Kajabi newsletter only to customers and recent clickers. Over three weeks she widens the audience. Her emails land well and replies keep coming.

Help Moving Your List

Moving your list is one of the most important parts of a migration. If you'd like it handled carefully, from export to warm-up, our Kajabi Expert Services can help.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I import my email list into Kajabi?

Yes. Kajabi lets you import contacts, usually from a CSV file, and apply tags during import. Check Kajabi's current help guidance for the exact steps and any limits.

Will my subscribers need to opt in again?

Not usually, if they genuinely opted in to receive your emails before. Keep records of how and when they signed up. Never import bought lists or people who didn't consent.

Should I tell subscribers I've moved platforms?

There's no need for a big announcement, but if your emails will look different or come from a new address, a short heads-up helps people recognise you.

Why warm up a list after moving?

Email providers notice sudden large sends from a new setup. Starting with engaged subscribers builds positive signals before you email everyone.

Written By

Geoffrey Moffett

More Articles
More In Kajabi

Back To Top