
Quick Answer
Business Improvement Districts should focus on click rates rather than open rates. Apple's Mail Privacy Protection pre-loads emails, inflating opens, so open rates are only a directional signal. A click is a conscious action. Also watch unsubscribe rate and list growth rate to see whether campaigns work.
Key Takeaways
- Apple's Mail Privacy Protection pre-loads emails and tracking pixels, so open rates are inflated and unreliable.
- Open rates still help as a directional signal when comparing campaigns, but should not be the main number.
- A click is a clear, unambiguous action and the signal that matters.
- BID clicks might mean registering for events, reading planning updates or taking up offers.
- Unsubscribe rate and list growth rate are other useful metrics.
In This Article
Email analytics can feel overwhelming at first. You log into your dashboard and you are met with percentages, graphs, and numbers that all seem important. But not all metrics are created equal, and for Business Improvement Districts, understanding which ones to focus on makes all the difference.
The Open Rate Situation
Let us address this head on. Open rates used to be the headline metric for email marketing. If your open rate was high, you assumed your content was landing well. If it was low, you would worry your subject lines needed work.
Then Apple changed things. With the introduction of Mail Privacy Protection, Apple’s Mail app pre-loads email content, including the tiny tracking pixel that records an “open”, regardless of whether the subscriber actually read the email. For any audience with a significant proportion of iPhone or Mac users, which is most audiences, this means open rates are now inflated and unreliable.
This does not mean open rates are worthless. They are still a useful directional signal, especially for comparing campaigns against each other. But they should not be the main number you are optimising for.
Click Rates Are Where The Real Story Is
A click is a clear, unambiguous action. When a subscriber clicks a link in your email, they made a conscious decision to engage. They wanted to know more. They took a step. That is the signal that matters.
For a BID, this might mean clicking through to register for an event, reading a planning update, exploring a new member business, or taking up a special offer. Every click is a meaningful interaction, and with a platform like MailerLite, you can see exactly which links were clicked, how many times, and by whom.
Other Metrics Worth Watching
- Unsubscribe rate: a spike here tells you something went wrong with a particular campaign
- List growth rate: are you gaining more subscribers than you are losing?
- Delivery rate: are your emails actually reaching inboxes?
- Revenue per email: if you are running paid events or campaigns with commercial outcomes, track this
What Sending From A Basic Email Client Leaves Out
If you are currently sending your BID communications from Outlook or Gmail, you have none of this. No open data, no click data, no delivery confirmation. You are investing time and effort into communications with no way to know if they are working. That is not a sustainable approach for an organisation that needs to demonstrate value to its levy payers and stakeholders.
Data drives decisions. When you know what is working, you can do more of it and stop wasting effort on what is not.
Get access to clear, actionable analytics from day one. Explore the platform here: MailerLite
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are email open rates unreliable?
Apple's Mail Privacy Protection pre-loads email content, including the tracking pixel that records an open, whether or not the subscriber read it. For audiences with many iPhone or Mac users, open rates are inflated.
Are open rates completely useless?
No. They remain a useful directional signal, especially for comparing campaigns against each other, but they should not be the main number you optimise for.
Why do click rates matter more?
A click shows a conscious decision to engage. For a BID that could be registering for an event, reading a planning update, exploring a member business or taking up an offer.
What other email metrics should BIDs watch?
Watch unsubscribe rate, because a spike suggests something went wrong with a campaign, and list growth rate, which shows whether you are gaining more subscribers than you are losing.