Business Improvement DistrictsAIDigital Marketing

A Quarterly AI Visibility Audit For Your Town Centre

How to check what ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews say about your town, score the answers, fix what's wrong and track progress every quarter.

Geoffrey Moffett 5 Min Read

Quick Answer

An AI visibility audit is a regular check of what AI assistants say when people ask about your town. You ask a fixed set of visitor-style questions in several AI tools, score the answers for accuracy and coverage, note which sources are used, then fix the content behind the gaps and repeat each quarter.

Key Takeaways

  • Use the same set of questions every quarter so results can be compared.
  • Score answers for accuracy, coverage of independents and freshness.
  • Note the sources AI tools cite, because that's where to focus fixes.
  • Turn every problem into a specific fix with an owner and a date.
In This Article

You'd never run a Christmas campaign without checking whether it worked. Yet most BIDs have no idea what AI assistants tell people about their town. An AI visibility audit changes that. It takes a couple of hours a quarter, needs nothing more than a spreadsheet and a few free AI tools, and gives you a clear list of things to fix.

Why An AI Visibility Audit Is Worth Doing

More visitors now plan their trips by asking AI: what to do, where to eat, when the market is on. If those answers are wrong or leave out your best businesses, it costs footfall quietly, with no complaint ever reaching you.

An audit also gives you something concrete to report. "In spring, two out of three AI tools didn't mention our independent shops. Now all three do" is the kind of progress your board and levy payers can understand.

Step 1: Write Your Question Set

Write fifteen to twenty questions that real visitors ask. Mix general and specific:

  • What are the best things to do in [town]?
  • Where can I have lunch in [town] centre?
  • Is there free parking in [town]?
  • What's on in [town] this month?
  • Is [town] good for a day out with kids?
  • Where can I buy gifts in [town]?
  • Is [town] accessible for wheelchair users?
  • What's [town] like in the evening?

Use the questions you hear at events, in emails and in social comments. Save the list. You'll use exactly the same wording every quarter.

Step 2: Choose Your Tools

Pick the AI tools your visitors are most likely to use. A sensible set might be Google with its AI features, plus a few popular assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude and Perplexity. Use a fresh session or private window where possible so previous chats don't influence answers.

Step 3: Record And Score

Set up a spreadsheet with one row per question per tool, and columns for:

ColumnWhat to record
Answer summaryA line on what it said
AccuracyCorrect, partly wrong or wrong
Independents mentionedYes, a few, none
FreshnessCurrent, out of date
Sources citedWebsites named or linked, if shown
NotesAnything odd or surprising

Keep scoring simple. You're looking for patterns, not precision.

Step 4: Look For Patterns

Once you've filled the sheet, step back and ask:

What's Consistently Wrong?

Old event dates, closed businesses, wrong parking information? These usually trace back to a specific source.

Who's Missing?

Are the same few chains or attractions mentioned every time, while your independents are invisible? That points to gaps in your directory and in members' own listings.

Which Sources Keep Appearing?

If tools cite a particular travel site, review platform or old news article, that source matters. If your own website never appears, that's your biggest opportunity.

Step 5: Turn Findings Into Fixes

For every problem, write a specific fix with an owner and a date.

ProblemLikely causeFixOwnerDate
Market day wrongOld page on our siteUpdate and add event dataEvents leadThis week
No cafés mentionedThin directory listingsRewrite top café listingsMarketingThis month
Parking info outdatedCouncil page changedUpdate our parking page and link to councilManagerThis month

Most fixes fall into a few buckets:

  • improve or create answer pages on your town website;
  • fix your business directory;
  • add structured data to events;
  • help levy payers update their Google Business Profiles;
  • ask third-party sites to correct old information.

Step 6: Repeat Every Quarter

Same questions, same tools, same scoring. Over a year you'll see whether answers are improving. Note any big changes in the tools themselves too, because AI products change often and that can shift results.

A Worked Example

Imagine a small market town runs its first audit. Across the tools, the answers to "where can I have lunch?" mostly mention two chain restaurants and a pub that closed last year. None of the town's independent cafés appear. Questions about parking repeat charges that changed in the spring.

The team traces the problems to three things: an old travel article still ranking well, thin café listings in the BID directory, and an out-of-date parking page on the town website. Fixes follow: a polite email to the travel site, rewritten café listings with specific descriptions, a refreshed parking page linking to the council's current charges, and a Google Business Profile session for hospitality businesses.

Next quarter, the closed pub has gone from most answers, and a couple of independent cafés start appearing. Not perfect, but clearly moving the right way, with evidence to show for it.

Sharing The Results

With The Board

A one-page summary: what improved, what's still wrong, what you're doing next.

With Levy Payers

Tell members whether their sector is showing up. "Our audit found AI tools rarely mention our hairdressers and barbers. Here's how to fix your listing." It's useful, specific and shows the BID working for them.

Pitfalls To Avoid

  • Changing the questions. You lose the ability to compare.
  • Over-reacting to one answer. AI answers vary. Look for trends.
  • Trying to trick the tools. Stuffing pages with keywords or fake reviews is a bad idea. Clear, accurate information is the only sustainable approach.
  • Auditing without fixing. The audit is only as valuable as the changes it leads to.

A Quarterly Checklist

  • Same question set and tools used.
  • Spreadsheet completed and dated.
  • Patterns noted.
  • Fix list with owners and dates.
  • Summary shared with board and members.

For a quick technical read on your own website alongside this, our AEO Scanner checks how well your pages are set up to be understood by AI.

How Starien Can Help

We run AI visibility audits for towns and help BIDs fix what they find, as part of Digital For BIDs. If you'd like us to run your first audit with you, or train your team to do it themselves, get in touch.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an AI visibility audit?

It's a structured check of how AI assistants and AI search features describe your town, its businesses and its events, used to find inaccuracies and gaps you can fix.

Which AI tools should we check?

Check the ones your visitors are likely to use. For most UK towns that means Google's AI features plus a few popular assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude and Perplexity. Keep the list the same each quarter.

Will answers be the same every time?

No. AI answers vary between sessions and over time. That's why you ask a fixed set of questions, record what you see on the day and look for trends over several quarters rather than reacting to one answer.

What do we do if an AI tool gets our town wrong?

Find where the wrong information likely comes from, fix it on your own site and any listings you control, ask other sites to update theirs, and publish clear, correct information that's easy to find.

Written By

Geoffrey Moffett

More Articles

Back To Top