KajabiEmail Marketing

How To Run A Re-Engagement Email Campaign For Your Course Creator List

Inactive subscribers drag down deliverability and morale. How to plan a kind, effective re-engagement email campaign for your Kajabi list, with sample emails.

Geoffrey Moffett 4 Min Read

Quick Answer

A re-engagement email campaign is a short series, usually three emails, sent to subscribers who haven't engaged for a while. It reminds them who you are, offers something genuinely useful and asks them to click if they want to stay. Those who don't respond can then be removed or moved to a less frequent list, which keeps your list healthy.

Key Takeaways

  • Inactive subscribers can quietly harm deliverability for everyone else.
  • Three short, honest emails are usually enough.
  • Make staying easy: one click should do it.
  • Letting people go is healthy, not a failure.
In This Article

Every email list gathers dust. People sign up for a freebie, change jobs, switch email addresses or simply lose interest. Over time, a growing share of your list stops opening or clicking. A re-engagement email campaign gives those people a friendly chance to come back, and lets you say a gracious goodbye to those who won't.

Why Inactive Subscribers Matter

It's tempting to keep everyone. Bigger numbers feel better. But a list full of unengaged contacts can cause real problems:

  • Deliverability. Email providers notice when lots of people ignore your emails. That can affect whether your emails reach the inbox of people who do want them.
  • Misleading numbers. Low engagement across a bloated list makes it hard to see what's working.
  • Cost. Many email plans charge by contact count.

A smaller, engaged list almost always beats a larger, sleepy one. We cover the bigger picture in email list hygiene for course creators.

Who To Include

Define "inactive" in a way that makes sense for you. A common approach:

  • no clicks in the last three to six months;
  • no purchases in that time;
  • not a current customer or member.

Open rates are less reliable than they used to be, because some email apps load images automatically. Clicks and purchases are better signals of real interest.

Never include current paying members in a "goodbye" campaign. They need different handling.

A Three-Email Re-Engagement Email Campaign

Email 1: The Friendly Check-In

Subject idea: Still want to hear from me?

Hi Alex,

It's been a while since you opened one of my emails, so I wanted to check in. Life's busy, and inboxes are busier.

If you'd still like tips on [your topic], just click below and you'll stay on the list.

[Yes, keep me on the list]

No hard feelings either way.

Short, honest, one link. The click can add a tag such as "Re-engaged" if your setup supports link-click tagging.

Email 2: Something Genuinely Useful

Subject idea: The 5-minute fix most people miss

Send your best, most practical piece of content. No sales pitch. The aim is to remind people why they signed up in the first place. Include the same "keep me on the list" link at the bottom.

Email 3: The Last Call

Subject idea: Shall we part ways?

Hi Alex,

I haven't heard from you in a while, so I'll stop emailing after this one. That keeps my list tidy and your inbox calmer.

If you'd like to stay, click here: [Keep me on the list]

Either way, thanks for being here. You're always welcome back.

This email often gets the most clicks. People respond to a clear, kind deadline.

Consider A "Less Often" Option

Some subscribers aren't uninterested. They're just overwhelmed. If you send a weekly email, a monthly digest or a "big news only" option may keep them on your list happily.

If your setup supports it, add a second link in each email: "Prefer to hear from me less often? Click here." Tag those people and send them a lighter schedule. It's a kind middle ground between "stay" and "go", and it can rescue relationships that would otherwise end.

Space Them Out

Send the three emails over about two weeks. For example: day 0, day 5 and day 12. Enough time for busy people to notice, not so long that the campaign drags.

What To Do Afterwards

Once the campaign ends:

  • Re-engaged subscribers: remove them from the inactive segment and welcome them back to your regular emails.
  • Non-responders: remove them from your list or move them to an archive, depending on your preference and your email plan.

Keep a record of what you did and when, so you can compare results next time.

Setting It Up In Kajabi

  1. Create a filter or segment for inactive contacts, based on the criteria you chose.
  2. Tag them as "Re-engagement: Started".
  3. Send the three emails, as broadcasts or a short sequence.
  4. Use link clicks to tag people who want to stay, where available.
  5. After the final email, review and remove non-responders.

If you'd like to run this automatically as people become inactive, it can become part of your behaviour-based automations, though inactivity triggers may need a regular manual step.

Writing Tips

  • Be honest. People appreciate straightforwardness.
  • Keep it short. These are quick decisions, not long reads.
  • One clear action. A single link to stay.
  • No guilt. "We miss you" is fine. "You're letting yourself down" is not.
  • Use your real voice. These emails should sound like you, not a template.

Learn From The Results

Look at who came back and who didn't. Did people from a particular lead magnet re-engage more? Did one source produce lots of inactive subscribers? Those patterns tell you which list-building activities attract genuinely interested people, and which just add numbers.

Pitfalls To Avoid

  • Including customers or members. They're not inactive subscribers.
  • Making it hard to stay. If people have to log in or fill in a form, many won't.
  • Running it constantly. Once or twice a year, or a single automated flow, is plenty.
  • Being afraid to let go. A smaller, engaged list is a good thing.

A Healthier List, Happier Inbox

A re-engagement campaign is one of the simplest ways to improve your email marketing. If you'd like help setting it up, writing the emails or tidying your list in Kajabi, our Kajabi Expert Services can help.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who counts as an inactive subscriber?

Typically someone who hasn't opened or clicked in a set period, often three to six months, and hasn't bought recently. Because open tracking is less reliable than it used to be, clicks and purchases are better signals.

How many emails should a re-engagement campaign have?

Three is common: a friendly check-in, a useful piece of content and a final 'shall we part ways?' email.

Should I delete subscribers who don't re-engage?

Usually yes, or at least stop emailing them regularly. Keeping lots of unengaged contacts can hurt deliverability and may cost you more on your email plan.

How often should I run a re-engagement campaign?

Once or twice a year works for most course creators, or as an automated sequence that runs whenever someone becomes inactive.

Written By

Geoffrey Moffett

More Articles
More In Kajabi

Back To Top