Quick Answer
To reach disengaged levy payers, first map who engages and who doesn't, then find out why through short personal conversations. Use the channels they already use, make small, easy asks, offer practical help relevant to their business, and keep contact regular, so relationships exist long before the next ballot.
Key Takeaways
- Map engagement so you know exactly who you're not reaching.
- Quiet businesses are often busy, not hostile. Find out the real reason.
- Small, relevant asks work better than invitations to big meetings.
- Personal contact, repeated over time, is the most reliable way to build trust.
In This Article
Every BID has its regulars: the board members, the enthusiasts, the businesses that turn up to everything. Then there's everyone else. The quiet ones who never open the newsletter, never come to meetings and only think about the BID when the levy bill arrives. Reaching disengaged levy payers isn't glamorous work, but it may be the most important engagement a BID does, especially with a ballot on the horizon.
Map Who You're Not Reaching
You can't fix what you can't see. Build a simple engagement map in a spreadsheet, one row per levy payer, with columns like:
- opened a newsletter in the last three months;
- attended any event, session or meeting this year;
- took part in a campaign;
- has a named contact the BID knows personally;
- last personal conversation.
Colour-code it. You'll quickly see which businesses are engaged, which are lukewarm and which have had no meaningful contact in a long time. Look for patterns: particular streets, sectors, or types of business, like offices or national chains.
Why Disengaged Levy Payers Go Quiet
Assumptions are dangerous here. Quiet doesn't always mean hostile. Common reasons include:
- Time: a sole trader who simply can't leave the shop.
- Relevance: an office occupier who thinks the BID is "for shops".
- Decision-making elsewhere: a chain store manager with no authority to engage.
- Missed connections: emails going to an old address or an absent owner.
- Past disappointment: something went wrong once and nobody followed up.
- Never asked: no one has ever personally invited them.
The only way to know is to ask.
The Listening Round
Plan a short programme of personal visits to your least engaged businesses. Keep it simple:
- Introduce yourself and the BID briefly.
- Ask three questions: How's business? What's the biggest challenge in the town for you? What would make the BID more useful to you?
- Listen. Don't defend.
- Note what you hear, and one specific follow-up.
- Do the follow-up within a week.
That last step is everything. A follow-up shows you listened, and it turns a visit into the start of a relationship.
Share The Load With Your Board
A BID team can't visit everyone alone. Ask each board member to adopt five or ten quiet businesses near their own, ideally in a similar sector. Their job is simple: say hello, ask the three listening questions, and pass back anything the BID should act on.
This works for several reasons. Board members are levy payers themselves, so they're credible. They're local, so conversations happen naturally. And it gives board members a clearer picture of what the wider membership thinks, which improves their decisions.
Give them a one-page briefing, the questions, and a quick way to report back, such as a short form or a message to the BID manager. Thank them publicly when the round is done.
Use The Right Channels
Disengaged businesses often aren't on your main channels. Try:
- In person: walkabouts at quiet times of day.
- Phone: a quick call to check details and invite them to something specific.
- Text or WhatsApp: where they've agreed, short practical messages.
- Printed one-pagers: left in person, with a QR code to more.
- Through other members: neighbours often know who to talk to.
Check your contact data too. A disengaged business may simply be receiving emails at an address nobody checks.
Make Small, Relevant Asks
"Come to our AGM" is a big ask for someone who barely knows you. Smaller asks work better:
- "Can we add your business to the town directory?"
- "Would you like your shop featured on our social channels?"
- "Can we help you set up your Christmas hours on Google?"
- "Would your staff like a free place at our social media session?"
Each small yes builds a little trust. Over time, bigger engagement follows.
Special Cases
National Chains
Store managers often can't commit to campaigns without head-office approval, but they can usually share local knowledge and display posters. Identify the regional or head-office contact for bigger asks.
Office Occupiers
Talk about what matters to them: a pleasant environment for staff, safety, places to eat at lunchtime, and staff discounts in town. Invite them to share BID offers with employees.
Absent Owners
Some businesses are run day to day by staff while the owner, who receives the levy bill, is elsewhere. Make sure you have a relationship with both.
Show Them Something Relevant
Once you understand a business, tailor what you share. A hair salon wants to hear about digital help and spotlights. A pub wants to know about night-time economy work. Our guide to telling your BID value story covers how to tailor messages by sector.
Track Progress
Update the engagement map monthly. Celebrate movement from grey to amber to green. A board report showing the number of businesses with a known personal contact rising over the year is meaningful evidence that the BID is reaching everyone, not just the usual faces.
Pitfalls To Avoid
- Treating quiet as hostile. Most quiet businesses are just busy.
- Only engaging before the ballot. Last-minute attention looks transactional. Start now.
- Overloading with information. Lead with one relevant thing.
- Not following up. A listening visit without action can make things worse.
- Relying on email alone. For this group, people beat inboxes.
A Re-Engagement Checklist
- Engagement map built and colour-coded.
- Listening round planned for the least engaged.
- Contact details checked and updated.
- Small asks ready for each sector.
- Follow-ups tracked and done within a week.
- Monthly progress update to the board.
How Starien Can Help
During six years supporting Coleraine BID, member engagement was at the heart of our work, from email to member digital-skills support. Through Digital For BIDs we help BIDs plan engagement that reaches everyone. If you'd like a fresh pair of eyes on yours, get in touch.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are some levy payers disengaged from their BID?
Common reasons include lack of time, not seeing what the BID does for them, feeling the BID favours other sectors, absentee owners or head-office management, and never having been personally asked.
How can a BID engage national chains?
Find the right contact, often a store manager locally plus someone at regional or head office, and offer things that fit their constraints, such as local campaign participation that doesn't require head-office sign-off.
Does engagement affect BID ballots?
Businesses that have a relationship with the BID are more likely to understand its value. Building engagement over the whole term reduces the risk of a ballot being decided by businesses who've never heard from you.
Filed Under