
Quick Answer
Growth comes from understanding why people buy, not from making the product better. In the milkshake example, sales stayed flat until the question changed from improving the shake to why people buy it. Commuters wanted something to pass the journey, so thicker shakes and faster pickup matched the moment and sales jumped.
Key Takeaways
- Tweaking recipes and testing flavours did not lift milkshake sales.
- Most milkshakes were bought early in the morning by commuters on long, boring drives.
- Thicker shakes, faster pickup and chunks inside fitted how the product was actually used.
- People buy in context: when busy, bored, stuck or wanting progress without friction.
- Ask why someone chooses your product in the first place, not only how to improve it.
In This Article
McDonald’s wanted to sell more milkshakes.
So they did what most businesses do:
They tweaked the recipe.
They tested new flavours.
They tried to make the product “better”.
Nothing changed.
Sales stayed flat.
So they changed the question.
Not:
“How do we improve the milkshake?”
But:
“Why do people buy milkshakes at all?”
That single shift changed the outcome.
People Don’t Buy Products. They Hire Them.
When they looked closer, a pattern appeared.
Most milkshakes were sold:
-
early in the morning
-
to commuters
-
during long, boring drives
People weren’t buying milkshakes for taste.
They were buying something to pass the time.
Something to do with their hands.
Something that lasted the journey.
The milkshake wasn’t the product.
The experience was.
Once that was clear, the solution was obvious.
The Fix Wasn’t More Features
They didn’t add more flavours.
They didn’t change the branding.
They didn’t redesign the cup.
They changed how the product fit into people’s lives:
-
Thicker shakes so they lasted longer
-
Faster pickup so commuters could grab and go
-
Chunks inside so it was more engaging
Sales jumped.
Not because the milkshake was better.
But because it finally matched the moment it was being used.
Strategy Is About Context
Most businesses focus on improving the thing.
Better features.
More options.
More polish.
But growth doesn’t come from polishing the product.
It comes from understanding the moment someone needs it.
People buy in context:
-
when they’re busy
-
when they’re bored
-
when they’re stuck
-
when they want progress without friction
If your product isn’t working, it’s often not because it’s bad.
It’s because it doesn’t fit cleanly into the real situation your customer is in.
Ask Better Questions
“How do we make this better?” is easy to ask.
“Why does someone choose this in the first place?” is harder.
But that’s the question that changes outcomes.
When you understand:
-
where someone is
-
what they’re feeling
-
what problem they’re trying to quietly solve
You stop guessing.
You start designing solutions that actually get used.
Build for Real Life
People don’t wake up thinking about products.
They think about:
-
getting through the day
-
making progress
-
avoiding friction
-
not wasting time
The best strategy isn’t adding more.
It’s fitting better.
Better fit beats better features.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the milkshake story about?
McDonald's wanted to sell more milkshakes and tried improving the product, but sales stayed flat. When they asked why people buy milkshakes, they found commuters wanted something to pass the time on a journey.
What changes boosted milkshake sales?
They did not add flavours, change the branding or redesign the cup. They made shakes thicker so they lasted longer, sped up pickup for grab-and-go commuters and added chunks to make them more engaging.
What does people hire products mean?
It means customers choose a product to do a job in a particular moment. The milkshake was not bought for taste but for the experience it provided during a commute.
What question should a small business ask?
Instead of asking how to make it better, ask why someone chooses this in the first place. If a product is not working, it often does not fit cleanly into the real situation your customer is in.
Filed Under