Web DevelopmentMarketing Services

Website Redesign Red Flags: What To Watch For Before You Sign

The warning signs that a website redesign could lose you rankings, enquiries or control of your own site, and the questions to ask before work begins.

Geoffrey Moffett 4 Min Read

Quick Answer

The biggest website redesign red flags are: no plan for redirecting old pages, no mention of measuring results before and after, unclear ownership of the domain and website, a proposal focused only on looks, and no plan for content. A good redesign protects what already works while fixing what doesn't.

Key Takeaways

  • A redesign without a redirect plan can wipe out years of search visibility.
  • You should own your domain, website and accounts, in writing.
  • Measure enquiries and traffic before the redesign so you can compare after.
  • Be wary of proposals that talk only about looks, not about customers or results.
In This Article

Website redesign red flags are worth knowing before you sign anything. A redesign should make your website better at its job: winning enquiries, sales or bookings. But every so often, a business launches a beautiful new site and watches its enquiries fall off a cliff. Usually, the warning signs were there from the start.

Here's what to watch for, and the questions to ask.

Why Website Redesign Red Flags Matter

Your current website, however tired it looks, may be doing more than you realise. Some pages might rank well in Google. Some old links from directories and press articles might still bring visitors. Your contact form might be quietly producing a steady trickle of work.

A redesign that ignores all that can throw the baby out with the bathwater. The goal is to keep what works and fix what doesn't.

Red Flag 1: No Redirect Plan

When page addresses change, every old link to them, from Google, other websites, old emails and bookmarks, can break. A redirect plan maps each important old page to its new equivalent, so people and search engines land in the right place.

Ask: "How will you handle redirects from our old pages?"

If the answer is vague, or if nobody's mentioned it at all, that's a serious red flag. Losing years of search visibility overnight is one of the most common and most avoidable redesign disasters.

Red Flag 2: Nobody Measures The Starting Point

How will you know if the redesign worked? Only by comparing before and after. Before work starts, someone should record:

  • Monthly enquiries, bookings or sales from the website.
  • Traffic and top sources.
  • Which pages bring in the most visitors.
  • Which searches you appear for in Google Search Console.

Ask: "What will we measure before and after launch?"

Our guide to website analytics for small businesses covers the numbers that matter.

Red Flag 3: Unclear Ownership

You should own your domain name, your content and your website, and have admin access to your hosting, analytics, Search Console and other accounts.

Watch out for:

  • The domain being registered in the designer's name.
  • Contracts that are vague about who owns the finished site.
  • Proprietary systems that make it hard to move your site elsewhere later.
  • Being told you can't have admin access "for your own protection".

Ask: "Will we own the domain, the website and all the accounts, and can we have that in writing?"

Red Flag 4: It's All About Looks

Design matters, but a proposal that talks only about colours, animations and "modern feel" is missing the point. A good redesign starts with questions like:

  • Who are your customers, and what do they need?
  • What should visitors do on the site?
  • What's working now, and what isn't?
  • Which pages bring in the most business?

Ask: "How will the redesign help us get more enquiries?"

Red Flag 5: No Plan For Content

Words and photos are what persuade people. A redesign that drops your old content into new templates, or leaves you to write everything at the last minute, often ends up with a pretty site full of thin or outdated text.

Ask: "Who is writing and updating the content, and when?"

Red Flag 6: Removing Pages That Work

Sometimes a designer wants to simplify by cutting pages. That can be good, but check first. A page that looks unimportant might be your best performer in search. Look at your analytics and Search Console before deleting anything, and redirect any pages you do remove.

Red Flag 7: Heavy, Slow Design

Big background videos, lots of animation and huge images can look stunning on a designer's large screen and crawl on a customer's phone. Ask to see the new site tested on mobile, on mobile data, before launch. Our guide to Core Web Vitals in plain English explains what to look for.

Red Flag 8: No Testing Or Launch Plan

A good launch includes checking:

  • Every form sends to the right place.
  • Phone numbers and buttons work.
  • Redirects work.
  • Analytics and conversion tracking work.
  • The site works on different phones and browsers.
  • Search engines are allowed to index the new site. (A setting left on from development can block them entirely.)

Ask: "What do you test before and after launch?"

Red Flag 9: No Aftercare

Websites need ongoing updates, security patches and small improvements. If nobody's mentioned what happens after launch, ask. Even if you plan to handle it yourself, you need to know how.

A Made-Up Example

A made-up kitchen company was offered a stunning redesign with a full-screen video and a new page structure. Nobody mentioned redirects or measurement. Before signing, they asked the questions above. The designer added a redirect plan, kept their three best-performing service pages, moved the video lower on the homepage, and agreed to record enquiries and traffic before and after. The new site launched without the usual dip.

Redesign Checklist

  • Redirect plan for every important old page.
  • Baseline numbers recorded before work starts.
  • Ownership of domain, site and accounts confirmed in writing.
  • Proposal focused on customers and results, not just looks.
  • Content plan agreed.
  • High-performing pages kept or carefully redirected.
  • Mobile speed tested.
  • Launch testing checklist in place.
  • Aftercare agreed.

Thinking About A Redesign?

If you're weighing up a redesign, our web development team can help you plan it so you keep what works and fix what doesn't. And if you're not sure whether you need a refresh or a full rebuild, our post on refreshing or rebuilding might help.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a website redesign hurt my Google rankings?

Yes, if it's handled carelessly. Changing page addresses without redirects, removing content that ranked well or launching with technical problems can all cause drops. A careful redesign plans for these and usually avoids lasting damage.

What is a redirect plan?

It's a list matching every important old page address to its new equivalent, so visitors and search engines following old links land in the right place. Without it, old links lead to error pages.

Who should own my website after a redesign?

You should own your domain name, your content and, ideally, the website itself, with admin access to your hosting, analytics and other accounts. Check the contract says so.

How do I know if a redesign worked?

Compare enquiries, sales, traffic and search visibility before and after launch, allowing a few weeks for things to settle. That's why it's important to record those numbers before work starts.

Written By

Geoffrey Moffett

More Articles
More In Web Development

Back To Top